ChrisMoody

Trade Happens Once every 10 Years - 100% Track Record Since 1900

INDEX:DJY0   DJIA
Trade Happens Once every 10 Years. 100% Track Record Since 1900.

Provided By Jake & Elliott Bernstein @ 2Chimps.net

Good Trade To Put In Your Journal...

See Chart Description for Specif Rules and Downloadable PDF written by Jake


Green Line = January in a year that ends in 5

Blue Line = December in a year that ends in 5

Rule - Monthly Chart. (See PDF for Details)

  • If We Get a Monthly Close Above January High Enter Long
  • Close Trade last day of the year.

Potential Symbols: DIA             , SPY             , Or Leveraged Versions...

No Losing years going back to 1900!

Only time trade did not work is 2005 and there was NO ENTRY Trigger.

Link to PDF:
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/77187122/TradingView%20Posts/2015%20Profits%20with%20the%20__Year%20Five__%20Pattern-%202chimps.net%20%E2%80%93%202Chimps.pdf
ITM.Trading
2 years ago
Curve fitting + too small of a sample size. Interesting nonetheless though.
+3 Reply
ChrisMoody PRO ITM.Trading
2 years ago
There is no question on the Sample size being too small if we were looking to develop a System...you absolutely correct.

However I would say that there have been many "Seasonal" type trades found using Presidential cycles, Years that end in X#, Specific years in Presidential Cycle based on what term they are in. These have worked so far...and the sample rate is low. This is too small of a sample set to base an entire trading plan on, but putting it in a basket of trades like the ones mentioned above....just works.

Where I am a little taken back is when you say it's Curve Fitting. I develop systems for a living...and Jake is one of the most respected Trading System Developers of our time. We found that years that end in 5 typically end UP for the year. To capitalize off a entire years move the highest time frame is 99.9% of the time the most reliable. Therefore a Monthly Close above the January High was a common sense one to test. This Trade Setup was noticed and announced before 2005 using the Monthly close. It didn't use to be a weekly or daily close and we changed it to Monthly after 2005. That would be Curve Fitting....Unrealistic...and in my opinion unethical.

Sample set too low to base an entire system on = YES. Curve Fitting...I have to respectfully disagree.
Reply
ITM.Trading ChrisMoody
2 years ago
Thanks for the reply Chris :)
Curve fitting doesn't have to be intentional and I am not saying it was intentional, so there is no need to mention ethics here. I understand that you simply did this as a matter of curiosity and I still did find it interesting despite flaws that you are already aware of.
Typically over optimization and curve fitting result in smaller sample sizes so they are very closely related concepts. In this case the 'years ending in 5' universe constraint has been applied to a simple entry rule. This has given you perfect expectancy but it has also reduced the sample size dramatically. However there is no real logical reason why you can't apply your entry rule to every year instead of just the years that end in 5. As a suggestion it would be interesting to see this same entry rule applied to every year over the past century. Even if that lowered the expectancy to the 55-60% range it would be a lot more meaningful and robust IMHO.
+1 Reply
2use
2 years ago
like..how did you even get to check this out?)
Reply
ChrisMoody PRO 2use
2 years ago
Easy...I have daily Dow data from pre 1900
Reply
beller
2 years ago
Larry Williams say that every year that end with 5 is a bullish year, appears that this is a trade on this Larry's consideration :-)
Reply
beller beller
2 years ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nk5XQ41mbuQ&spfreload=10
Reply
Ideas Scripts Chart
United States
United Kingdom
India
España
Italia
Brasil
Россия
Türkiye
日本
한국
Home Stock Screener Economic Calendar How It Works Chart Features House Rules Moderators For the WEB Widgets Stock Charting Library Priority Support Feature Request Blog & News FAQ Help & Wiki Twitter
Private Messages Chat Ideas Published Followers Following Priority Support Public Profile Profile Settings Billing Sign Out